Economists Urge FM Sitharaman to Retain Equity Capital Gains Tax in Budget 2027-28
Leading economists advised Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman to retain equity capital gains taxes in Budget 2027-28, resisting industry demands for tax cuts.

Key Takeaways
- In pre-Budget consultations with Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, leading economists recommended retaining current capital gains tax rates on equities.
- The policy advice pushes back against corporate lobbying from chambers of commerce seeking to eliminate or lower the 12.5% LTCG and 20% STCG rates.
- Economists emphasized that maintaining tax buoyancy on capital assets is critical to sustain fiscal deficit consolidation toward the 4.5% target.
In high-level pre-Budget consultative meetings convened by Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Monday ahead of the Union Budget for fiscal year 2027–28, leading economic advisors and fiscal policy experts explicitly recommended that the government retain current capital gains tax rates on equity investments, resisting lobbying from industry bodies for tax rollbacks.
What Happened
The consultations brought together senior economic advisors, public finance scholars, and representatives from the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) alongside the Finance Minister. Several prominent business associations and retail investor groups had submitted pre-budget representations calling for the reduction or repeal of long-term capital gains (LTCG) tax on listed equities—which was revised to 12.5% in 2024—and a rollback of short-term capital gains (STCG) tax from 20% to 15%. However, economists unanimously argued that diluting equity capital gains taxes would compromise tax buoyancy, disproportionately benefit top wealth brackets, and erode direct tax revenue needed for state-backed capital expenditure programs.
Direct Tax & Capital Gains Framework Snapshot (Union Budget Consultations)
| Tax Metric / Policy Parameter | Current Statutory Rate (2026) | Industry Lobby Proposal | Economists' Consensus Stance | Fiscal Impact on Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) | 12.50% on Listed Equities | Cut to 10.0% or Abolish | Retain at 12.50% Flat Rate | Protects ~₹42,000 Cr Direct Tax Intake |
| Annual LTCG Exemption Threshold | ₹1.25 Lakh per Fiscal Year | Expand to ₹2.50 Lakh | Hold at ₹1.25 Lakh Ceiling | Prevents Narrowing of Base |
| Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG) | 20.00% on Holdings < 12M | Reduce to 15.00% Rate | Retain at 20.00% Rate | Curbs Speculative Intraday Flipping |
| Securities Transaction Tax (STT) | 0.02% on F&O Contracts | Cut Derivatives Surcharge | Maintain Enhanced Rates | Deters Unregulated F&O Retail Losses |
| Fiscal Deficit Consolidation Goal | 4.90% of GDP (FY26 Target) | Relax Deficit Glidepath | Consolidate to 4.50% of GDP | Essential for Sovereign Rating Upgrades |
| Gross Direct Tax Intake (Budget) | ₹22.37 Lakh Cr Projected | Narrow Direct Tax Net | Expand Wealth & Asset Buoyancy | Funds ₹11.1 Lakh Cr Infrastructure Capex |
The Ministry of Finance indicated that while all stakeholder submissions are subject to internal departmental modeling, tax policy must align with the government's medium-term fiscal glidepath targeting a fiscal deficit below 4.5% of GDP by FY28.
Policy Context & Transmission
The debate underscores an enduring fiscal policy tension between capital market competitiveness and progressive taxation. India's equity capital gains collections have expanded rapidly over the past four fiscal years, driven by record domestic stock market capitalizations and surging corporate profitability. Eliminating or softening capital gains taxation would create a substantial revenue shortfall of roughly ₹42,000 crore annually, forcing the government to either compress infrastructure capital expenditure or increase regressive indirect taxes on fuel and consumer commodities.
Independent TradeKaizen Analysis & Key Risks
TradeKaizen Analysis: The economists' recommendation to hold the line on equity capital gains taxes represents sound fiscal stewardship. With domestic equity markets demonstrating robust liquidity and benchmark indices trading near record highs, there is no empirical evidence that a 12.5% LTCG rate has deterred long-term capital allocation or dampened mutual fund SIP participation. Retaining tax policy stability provides predictability for foreign portfolio investors, while ensuring that capital gains contribute their equitable share toward public capital formation and fiscal deficit reduction.
Key risks include temporary market volatility leading into the February 1 Budget presentation as speculative options traders price in tax rumors, potential redirection of short-term hot money flows toward lower-tax regional jurisdictions like Singapore or Dubai, and persistent retail disquiet regarding differential taxation between financial gains and real estate assets.
Disclaimer: This report is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
Sources & References
- View sourceMinistry of FinanceExchange / Regulatory Filing
Pre-Budget Consultations for Union Budget 2027-28: Summary Record of Discussions with Leading Economists
- View sourceThe Economic TimesNews Report
Retain Capital Gains Tax on Equities, Economists Tell FM Sitharaman Ahead of Budget 2027-28
TradeKaizen Markets Desk
Equities & Market Coverage Desk
The TradeKaizen Markets Desk covers Indian equities, index movements, institutional flows, and exchange disclosures from NSE and BSE.
